The client was charged with failing to provide. The issues in the case were loss of confidence in the police due to grossly disproportionate force at the time of arrest and reasonable excuse due to mental state at the time of the breath test. The client had been thrown to the ground and handcuffed after asking to call his partner. Body cam footage confirmed the arresting officers were abusive towards the client. The prosecution offered no evidence at the second hearing which was listed for trial after James Yearsley instructed by Sandra Cooper (reviewing lawyer) raised the failure by police to disclose CCTV and the non-attendance of the arresting officer after successfully opposing a video link application by the prosecution.